(260) 480-0208

Monday to Friday: 8am to 5pm EST
Evenings & Weekends by Appointment

About Us

Where We're Located

Our agency is located in Fort Wayne in the Papermill Office Park off of St Joe Center Road. We welcome you to submit a request for a quote and then come in and talk with one of our friendly agents. All customer service is handled in our local Fort Wayne office.

Why Us?

Schultheis Agency is an agent for the customer. We will quote your specific insurance request with several financially strong insurance carriers to see which insurance company is most competitively priced for you.  We not only do this at the start of your policy, but we do this is an ongoing effort. We will continue to shop markets for you upon your renewal and upon your request.  We are consistently looking for the best pricing based on your specific risk profile.

Who We Are: Local Family-Owned Business Serving You

The Schultheis Agency is an independent insurance agency which has been serving the Fort Wayne area since 1975.  With Fort Wayne Car Insurance.com and Schultheis Agency you have the best of both worlds, the convenience of on-line 24/7 accessibility, with a highly skilled Fort Wayne agency staff ready to answer any questions or concerns. Unlike many of the dot com insurance carriers, FortWaynecarinsurance is local and family owned.  We’re here for our customers in our own home town. Stop by our office in the Papermill Office park and interview an agent to represent you and your insurance needs.